• Home
  • Book Reviews
  • Books
    • Monthly Wrap Up
    • Giveaways
    • Book Hauls
    • Events
  • Discussions
  • New Releases
  • Features
    • Top Ten Tuesday
    • Romance Thursdays
    • Movie Reviews
    • TV Series Reviews
    • Waiting on Wednesday
  • #LoveOzYA
    • OZYA Interviews
    • OZYA Reviews
  • About
  • Contact
Angel ReadsAngel Reads
  • Home
  • Book Reviews
  • Books
    • Monthly Wrap Up
    • Giveaways
    • Book Hauls
    • Events
  • Discussions
  • New Releases
  • Features
    • Top Ten Tuesday
    • Romance Thursdays
    • Movie Reviews
    • TV Series Reviews
    • Waiting on Wednesday
  • #LoveOzYA
    • OZYA Interviews
    • OZYA Reviews
  • About
  • Contact

Discussion: Casting Adaptations

Home DiscussionsDiscussion: Casting Adaptations

Discussion: Casting Adaptations

May 2, 2015 Posted by angelreads Discussions 7 Comments

discussion

If you follow me on Twitter you have almost certainly have seen me rant about this. But with all the negatively that I’m seeing in Facebook comments and on twitter I feel that I need to say something.

Casting for a movie or TV show is certainly not going to be 100% spot on. There are few reasons why and I am going to try to tell you why.

Primarily since an author doesn’t create a character from a person that already exists, the person that they cast will not look exactly the same. The author creates a character from his or hers mind so when somebody is cast as them, they aren’t going to have the same appearance, as this character is not real.

Another issue is that people also create their own version of a character when they are reading. This could be totally different from the author’s formation of this person. All of us, imagine characters in diverse ways.

People cannot go and accuse casting directors, anyone connected to the adaptation or even the author for that matter that who was cast, is horrible and isn’t that character. Since that is who they pictured.

If you don’t know what has happened with the recent casting of a few key characters in The Mortal Instruments series by Cassandra Clare, new TV series ‘Shadowhunters‘ then all you need to do is go and check on twitter or on Facebook posts about it and just look in the comments.

10423936_450029978506540_5096909444618642057_n
Three characters have been cast at the moment. When Dominic Sheerwood was cast as Jace the response was pretty acceptable for the most part. But last night when Izzy and Simon were cast there was mayhem and people were and still are horrible.

Alberto Rosende was cast as Simon and after merely seeing just a head shot (that is professionally taken), people judged him. Even before they had even saw him in character. However since then people have calmed down, only after they were able to see him with glasses in his introduction video.  Yet people are still saying that he is not “geeky looking.” Yet the thing is, the only tributes that make him geeky are his glasses, his clothes and how he acts but once he turns into a vampire he changes. He loses the glasses and becomes “hot” and Alberto has it all.

Now to Isabelle. Emeraude Toubia is absolutely, stunningly gorgeous.  Yes her skin may be darker than what is alleged in the books but she has the appearance of Izzy in ever shape and form. There are edits already with Emeraude in black clothes and tats and she looks pretty damn awesome.


11204989_457212781121593_7708191089620988890_n (1)

People likewise keep on going, on about how they are using unknown actors. However, yes they may be unfamiliar but for all we could know, they could be unbelievable actors.

Also when people say that the person cast doesn’t have the exact hair or eye colour, I just believe that these people don’t use their brain. Like seriously its called hair dye (do people think that my hair is naturally pink) and also there is a thing called eye contacts.

The thing that is irritating me the most throughout this whole thing, like a fly that doesn’t want to leave you alone. Is that people want the movie characters back. People need to get it into their thick skulls the movie cast are not going to come back. I don’t understand how small-minded some people are. I am not trying to offend people here but it is not going to happen and I will tell you why.

The movie was not good! Simple, the script was to cliché. A lot of the cast could not act and I am sorry to say that. Don’t get me wrong I love Jamie and Lily and all the cast, but they were just not right (and I am not talking about looks here). There was no spark between Jace and Clary, and that did hinder the movie because the romance plays such a vital role.

I know that some people love the old cast and that is totally acceptable but you need to get over it. They will not be in the TV show. The movie and the TV series are two very separate things and starting with a new cast and crew is a good way to go in hope of a successful series.

Truly, I cannot wait to watch Shadowhunters and see all the action if anything goes by how they are casting, I think the books are in respectable hands and I am hoping that the script and the rest of the cast add to it. Shadowhunters is set to hit out TV screens early 2016.

Stay in tune with the show and like their Facebook page, twitter and Instagram. Also stay in touch with me by following me through bloglovin’ and liking my Facebook page and twitter.

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

7 Comments
Share

7 Comments

Leave your reply.
  • Francoise
    · Reply

    May 3, 2015 at 11:01 AM

    All of us picture characters differently obviously but I think why people are usually so upset over casting is because sometimes the don’t fit the basic description. For example, Anabeth from the Percy Jackson series! She has blond hair in the books and it’s a running joke throughout the series because she’s super smart and doesn’t fit the ‘blond jokes criteria. But in the movie they changed her to a Brunette so it sort of killed it.

    I love it when directors use unknown actors because it gives them a chance at their dreams. I can’t understand why people would complain that because who wants to see the same actors all the time? I totally agree, the movie was incredibly cheesy (although I still enjoyed) I’m excited to see this as a series. I had no idea this was happening!

    Great post Angel!

    Loading...
    • angelreads
      · Reply

      Author
      May 3, 2015 at 7:27 PM

      I understand that, but I know I would rather someone who can act then someone who is awful and has what ever is missing. The thing with Percy Jackson is that it wasn’t a book to movie adaptation, it was a movie based very loosely on a book. They did change her hair colour in the second movie but yet I understand.
      I love the use of unknown actors because it lets us see people that are not all in the media yet, and if they can act hey they found a new star. So cheesy and really different from the book which made me really dislike it.

      Thank you and thanks for commenting

      Loading...
  • Renee Bookboyfriends
    · Reply

    May 3, 2015 at 2:51 PM

    I cannot wait to watch Shadowhunter either! And even though Dom was our Christian, I’m loving seeing him around acting like Jace and I can TOTALLY see it! I can! And I’m like, wow! He has that Jace arrogance and enthusiasm and I can’t wait for them to cast Clary!
    I am so excited about Alberto and Emeraud! I LOVE THEM!!! I wasn’t so keen about Isabelle in the movie, like she was okay, but didn’t have that fierceness or badass vibe about her as much. I LOVE EMERAUD!!! 😀 😀 😀 I actually am so excited for her! And Alberto was so cute in his thankyou video and like you said, yeah I can see him turning hot and omg I hope they keep that rat scene! ha ha ha ha And omg imagine COHF and ‘Lord Montgomery’ with those two!!! XD XD XD Thanks for sharing Angel!!! xoxo

    Loading...
    • angelreads
      · Reply

      Author
      May 3, 2015 at 7:28 PM

      Dom, Dom, Dom my love haha. I think that Christian and Jace are very similar and he can totally pull Jace off, I can see it already.

      hahaah, you crack me up. I am so excited for the rest of the cast. Thanks for commenting

      Loading...
  • Joy @ Thoughts By J
    · Reply

    May 10, 2015 at 3:18 PM

    I absolutely agree with you 100% Angel. Everyone needs to step back and let the professionals do the work here. Obviously the casting directors saw the potential in these people, so they cast them. It’s how the world works and I wish more people understood this instead of being nasty about the casting choices. I for one LOVE the upcoming cast. The movie was rightfully horrible, so I’m glad they’re actually starting from scratch. So excited for this show, 2016 cannot come soon enough!

    Loading...
    • angelreads
      · Reply

      Author
      May 10, 2015 at 5:47 PM

      yes! People just fustrate me to the core. I totally agree I LOVE this cast, and who has just recently been added.To tell you the turth I didn’t like the movie really at all.
      Yay. Glad that you are excited for the show too, I need it now haha

      Loading...

Leave a Reply

Your email is safe with us.
Cancel Reply

Recent Posts

  • Books Covers With Typography That I Love | TTT
  • New To Me Authors I Loved in 2025
  • My Favourite Reads of 2025
  • Most Anticipated Books Releasing in the First Half of 2026
  • Slow but an Okay August | Monthly Wrap Up

Subscribe to Angel Reads

Enter your email address to subscribe to Angel Reads and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Bookstagram

angelreads

book blogger 💻| romance books 💜| bookseller 📖
💌 angel@angelreads.com
📚15/150

I have a love-hate relationship with this series. I have a love-hate relationship with this series. But I ended up really enjoying this one. It’s best friends to fake dating to-lovers. It’s always been you, bad-boy/good-girl, and I loved that. While Save Your Breath has quite a few tropes, it really leads itself to it, and it works. 

Aleks and Mia have known each other for years now. Since they were teenagers, that angst has been building up this whole time. And you can tell right from the get-go, it’s fantastic. I even wanted more of it, because I love pain. When Aleks went to live with Mia’s family as a teenager, sparks flew, but for many reasons, they both put their feelings aside. And well, now they are not only going to be fake-dating, but they might as well be engaged, too. 

I really enjoyed seeing how both Aleks and Mia both tried to hide how they were feeling throughout the whole ‘fake-dating’ situation, but anyone could see it. They know each other as no one else does. Aleks has a lot going on, and while I do think this was brushed over a little too much, Mia is his centre. Mia is a massive music star and is a female in the industry, so yeah, people don’t respect her. Obvsiouly because why couldn’t a female star be badass and write about the things that she has gone through? Aleks and Mia get each other, and that is very clear from the start; they are both just trying to squash everything. We get to see them slowly start to show how they feel, and well, one night it all explodes. 

Overall, I enjoyed this one a lot; it’s not my favourite of the series, but I had a great time reading it. I liked Aleks and Mia a lot as characeters and while I think the mental health aspect could have been explored a whole lot more, I can see why it wasn’t. The romance was slow and spicy, the angst was great, and the payoff for these two was what they needed. 

Tropes
🏒Sports/Hockey Romance
🎤Fake Dating/Engagement
🏒Childhood Friends to Lovers
🎤Forced Proximity
🏒Athlete x Pop Star 
🎤Angsty Slow Burn 

Content Warnings
Mental Health Struggles 
Suicide Intention 
Family Deaths 
Alcohol Consumption
Violence on Ice

🏷️ 
#romancebooks #bookstagram  #angelreads #spicybooks #bookreview
Well February wasn’t the best reading month. I onl Well February wasn’t the best reading month. I only ended up reading 3 books in. 3 pretty fun books but one of my slowest readings months in a while. 

And I’m going to be honest here it’s because I’ve been constantly reading Heated Rivalry fanfics. 🤷‍♀️ I’m having the best time though. 

How was your reading in February? Any 5  star reads? 

🏷️ 
#romancebooks #bookstagram  #angelreads #spicybooks #februarywrapup
January was a really solid reading month. I read s January was a really solid reading month. I read some books that had been on my tbr for some time, reread a few things that peaked my interest. I also started a few new series. And just had a good time!

I just had a really good start to the year. While February is a little slow so far I’m looking forward to what I can pick up.

What did you read in January? Any 5-star reads? Let’s chat! 

🏷️ 
#romancebooks #bookstagram  #angelreads #spicybooks #januarywrapup
Can you believe that it’s already February? I know Can you believe that it’s already February? I know I can’t. But that means it’s a new month with more releases coming out! And that makes me excited. Some fantastic titles releasing this month and I cannot wait to read them. 📚

A couple of these are on my TBR already and some have just caught my eye and that makes me super excited to pick them up. 🖤

What are you looking forward to reading this month? Let’s chat! ✨

🏷️ 
#romancebooks #bookstagram  #angelreads #spicybooks #Februaryreleases2026
Follow on Instagram

GoodReads

2026 Reading Challenge

2026 Reading Challenge
Angel - Angel Reads has read 0 books toward her goal of 150 books.
hide
0 of 150 (0%)
view books

Contact Us

Send us an email and I'll get back to you, asap.

Send Message

© 2013 - 2026 · Angel Reads · Disclaimer

Prev Next
%d